Can the Axis trace supply through an Active but Non-Hostle VF? RAW 2.4.2 Limits on supply paths "You can't trace any supply path:.....ï into a hex controlled...
I don't see any way to interpret it otherwise - active Vichy allows supply. Bill P ... From: Tom_S_Bell Date: Tuesday, January 1, 2008 4:14 pm Subject:...
In our FT game I claimed Bessrabia and my Axis opponent denied both Bu & Hu land claims. This was in direct response to my build up for invading Bulgaria. It...
Why not claim Bess and DOW Bulgaria the same impulse? Just like the CW can see if the US makes it's war roll before DOWing you get to have the claims resolved...
I am not sure this is possible to wait for the result and then DoW Bulgaria since all DoW must be announced in the step. So Russia would have to claim...
In the case of the CW vs Japan, the rules are not terribly clear, but I seem to remember Harry ruling in favor of Lane's interpretation. In the case of the...
Yeah,aligning to Italy is attractive, but you can only do this if Italy is active at the time of the russian dow. ... Bu & Hu ... invading ... invade it. ... ...
... for aligning them, so that's a wash. More or less. Remember that average chit value in 1939 is about 50% higher than in 1940, so there is still a...
Hello, I have two questions that pertain to flying planes in the Red Sea area (we are *not* playing with the African mini-map): 1. My understanding is that if...
Neither of those are so. The CW does get to see if the US makes a DOW or not before it chooses to make a DOW. Furthermore, the USSR does get to know how the...
... Maybe Harry has ruled this, but it doesn't match other rules. For example, you can't wait to see how one attack goes before declaring a second attack....
In a message dated 1/2/2008 11:20:27 PM Central Standard Time, ... Two good questions. ... There is an incorrect assumption here. Sudan is not adjacent ot the...
G'day guys, I have been reading the regular posts about the final reorg for units staying at sea. It ends with the following arguments: - tracing a path back...
14.1.1 and 14.1.2 have the A/C movement costs. It only states the movement cost to enter a hex or hex-dot. It is strange, but it is correctly stated below....
... It would be physically and mentally difficult to complete all attacks "in parallel". They are complicated, so we do them serially. It is trivial to say...
Units at sea are always in supply and can trace to any oil on the board. It's always been that way and that's how Harry says to play it. That aside your...
It also costs 1 to move from a swamp to a clear hex but costs 5 to move back into the swamp. It does not have to logically follow that moving along one...
Yes that is the ruling from Harry. I previously joined the "significant list" - also to no avail. It bugs our group enough to house rule it. Our rule is that...
Why would this need to match some other rule ? For what it's worth, it matches the "I initiate a search in that sea area, roll search rolls, resolve naval...
Jérôme, about that, we asked Harry, for the future official FAQ. Yes the CW knows whether the USA succeed in DoWing the Axis or not before making their DoW,...
Thanks to both! Joe ________________________________ From: wifdiscussion@yahoogroups.com on behalf of Conrad Vogelsang Sent: Thu 1/3/2008 11:41 AM To:...
Just to confirm ... does that mean the mission can't be flown? That is, if you have a 10-range unit, and it takes 9 movement points to get somewhere, and 14 to...
... sea area, ... etc..., and ... Because the rules for naval searches are explicit. OTOH, the rules for DoW are clear (in RaW7.) 9.2 All major powers on this...
The rules are unclear on whether you can fly a mission if you have range to the target hex but not to return to base; my guess is that Harry did not think of...
Which does not contradict what Harry said that I quoted in the other mail. I don't think that Harry is wrong, but I did not follow all the discussion, I don't...
Having problems with message search?
Fill out this form to ensure your group is one of the first to be migrated to the new message search system.
