Bill is 101% right ! ... as 2) in clear weather, rail supply (the last one only, back to a primary supply source) may include rail (and sea, for 1 hex cost)...
My apologies if this has been asked before, but can the Allied player place Polish partisans in the Eastern (Soviet controlled) portion of Poland (prior to...
You place partisans in enemy controlled hexes. ... -- ... Think of how stupid the average person is, and realize half of them are stupider than that....
This question is part of the questions that we have for Harry Rowland (for clarifying MWiF). It was submitted to him 3 days ago (with 47 others), I'm still...
That's not the question that was asked. "Can the allied player place partisans in Soviet controlled hexes in East Poland" The answer is no, with no room for...
I could be convinced to support some simplification of cooperation rules but again, I think it should be done very carefully if at all, not just with a...
This is certainly better than just getting rid of all cooperation rules, although I'm not sure I really WANT to get rid of current cooperation rules. Again, I...
Lane's major objection seems to be transporting offbeat corps by sea on minor TRS (Like TERR on the Dutch TRS). Since ships already can cooperate ("stack" if...
Certainly the MP issues need to be kept. It's the minor country issues that IMO are not worth the bother. Yes RUM and HUN didn't like each other. Is that...
Isn't the SA Terr a major power unit? South African, Indian, N. Irish, Canadian, Australian, New Zealand TERRs I understood counted as MP units, no different...
There is a lengthy debate on this starting with message #89792. The answer could be yes or no right now depending on how the persuasiveness of the opinions...
This is true, its the Rhodesian, Ugandan, etc. territorials the Dutch TRS can't transport - until the Dutch are completely conquered - then you're fine -...
Rich, your interpretation is quite incorrect I think. First, being an enemy and being on the other side are not identical concepts. They are defined in the RAW...
As a avid reader of Polish History, and being sensitive to political nuance concerning poland I would say that the partisan is anti german essentially, polish...
Yes. Territorials are not 'special' in any way with respect to whether they are minor/major country units. You take a look at what type of unit it is (SA /...
IMO the trouble is not with MP countries and the cooperation works well and is historic. No one that I know has advocated the change of cooperation and MP...
In this case "HR" I think means ruled by Harry Rowland and not "House Rule". Kind of humorous that that coincidental misunderstanding can exist. :) ... well...
I did not see the definition of enemy in the glossary before and I cannot find the rule I was looking at before maybe I was looking at an older version. So I...
Hi ! A question has come up in our DoD3-Wiffe game in Sweden. The neutral (after a conditional Chinese surrender) Japanese player argues that since US...
One suggestion for any change would be to erase the stacking prohibition from the cooperation rules, but add a +2 modifier in land combat against a hex...
We've tried making partisans in a USSR controlled Eastern Poland via House Rules. And even after seeing them on the map while Russia was off having adventures...
This was a long discussion, recently, and I believe no dispute was found which prevents the Allies from putting partisans in East Poland(Russian controlled)...
We often send the Brazilians to secondary fronts to fill the line against the Axis, sometimes Italy, more often the Balkans or Spain. THey serve their...
Enemy [a major power or minor country you are at war with] From the glossary in the back of the Aug 04 rules. Bill P ... From: RG1066@... Date: Monday,...
If that's the case, nobody bothered consulting the rules. The controlling MP (in this case, the CW) places the partisans, and places them in enemy controlled...
For better or worse, RAW seems to allow the CW to place a partisan in East Poland as long as its placed more than 3 hexes from the partition line. Why? Firstly...
Really, the major non-cooperating minors problems are all on the Axis side. Although if you look at the pre-war attitudes in places like Belgium and...
US entry options are chosen during the US Entry step, after the movement and all that is finished. The US declares war during an impulse. I don't believe that...
I agree with Tom. The only positive thing I hear about the cooperation issues with minors is simple historical constraints of some specific minors. It's...
Having problems with message search?
Fill out this form to ensure your group is one of the first to be migrated to the new message search system.
