The essential mechanic that IMO you are missing is the 1st sentence of 2.4.2 : "To be in supply a unit must be able to trace a supply path..." Your entire...
If it is of any help it is the act of ending it's move that debarks the unit. Nothing in the rules would allow you to debark and keep moving either. Lane...
Also in 2.4.2 is "You trace a supply path from a unit to a primary supply source." Go to my example of a HQ operating out of country all by itself where no ...
Yes, I think I was just being dense about the whole thing. Paralysis by analysis. The thing of it is I never believed it was possible. It's just that when I...
Question, if the UK has a mosquito with nav points, when searching for ships etc, when do they have to declare as a fighter or as a bomber, and when they do do...
At the begining of each round of naval air combat you arrange all your aircraft into two columns, one of fighters, one of bombers. They keep that designation...
John: Don't make this more difficult then it is: From 11.4.5 Naval transport, "Debarking in port If a TRS ends its move in a port, any cargo debarks ...
Clearly, you are comparing apples and telephones. ... From: lupi@... Date: Monday, April 30, 2007 4:11 pm Subject: Re: [wifdiscussion] Re: HQ Supply To:...
Your quotation of this sentence marks the crux of your fallacy. The sentence does not insist that every unit trace a basic supply path. Units not capable of...
Only when lining up the planes (secretly) each combat round, and may change their decision (privately) from one round to the next. The opponent will not know...
Hello all, In the 1939 Global War scenario set up, the CW is allocated "any map" land units. The language used to delineate set-up restrictions on the Asian...
The only time you may trace a railway supply line is when a secondary source is directly tracing to a primary source. Quote the line in the RAW that states a...
Check my posts, it's been quoted three times. Give up already. ... secondary source is directly tracing to a primary source. ... line only for itself may...
Actually, you haven't posted a relevant RAW statement for this matter yet. Eric Sent via BlackBerry from T-Mobile ... From: "kenzclark" <kenzclark@...> ...
He can't set up in the "may not enter" areas. Rich Gause ... From: ssw193@... To: wifdiscussion@yahoogroups.com Sent: Tue, 1 May 2007 2:14 PM Subject:...
I sense the HQ Supply debate is about to wander into personal attack territory, so I thought I'd actually be pre-emptive for a change and ask people to keep...
This language has been debated in various areas of the rules. It has always as far as I know been interpreted that units which must set up, such as units of a...
No line needed. It would be inherent in the description of an HQ AS a secondary supply source. ... From: lupi@... Date: Tuesday, May 1, 2007 2:23 pm ...
Here is the question I've asked to be answered. Take a player opening a WIF box for the first time. This player picks a country. He assumes that the country...
gentlemen, Thanks for the responses. We disallowed and house ruled the ability of the CW to set up in Rabaul in 1939, but agreed it'd be a good idea to check...
When I started playing WIF with my group, none of whom had played WIF before, we were able to figure out that an HQ traces from itself as a secondary supply...
That is your entire problem with this concept. I have pointed out twice that it is what the rules say and for whatever reason you choose to ignore it. The...
For someone talking about tantrums it's nice that you did not answer the question asked again showing the point of the question. "when everyone else agrees how...
Since Devin has stepped in I'll make this nice. I'll make the assumption that you truly are interested in the debate and are not trolling. I cited the exact...
A unit traces a basic supply path from itself to a primary supply source. Alternatively a unit may trace a basic supply path to a secondary supply source that...
Having problems with message search?
Fill out this form to ensure your group is one of the first to be migrated to the new message search system.
