i doubt that. will ge not align finland because rumania, bulga and hungary all led to a chit? harold p.s. i believe toxic gas is lif past. ... will stop his...
assumes partisans 2d10 almost presumes divs and guns. imo attack weakness yes/no is negligible in the beginning but i might be wrong. maybe chinas solutionis...
i believe there's a chance for ru to draw 2 white cricle atr ... harold ... active... ... is ... IT ... in the ... SCS to ... is ... not a ... DoW ... in ... ...
its you call. harold ... to ... geared ... Only ... were ... wants, ... Jap ... harden ... to ... is ... seen ... after ... how ... of ... russia ... turn; ......
imo it would make a huge difference. same for persia, which some russians do right away in s/o 39. if you want to have the threat / potential to dow jp with...
Hi, As an alternative, I re-submit a rules proposal from a month or so ago addressing this problem: "Diesel is Diesel" Allow Germany (only) to take one naval...
Israel Zuckerman
izzyz@...
Mar 1, 2006 8:36 am
84014
What? 2 extra R to RU and 2 fewer to GE (which isn't true btw, as Yug R will compensate) not worth an US entry hit? In 39? You must be joking. ... <<When you...
And that doesn't include the extra BP it generates for RU. ... Lane you think the USE hit is worth more then the possible lose of BPs to Ge. I would not be so...
1) You are wrong regarding what the "debate" involved- except in your own mind. 2) Your "my point of view" that that there was "doctrine" to use guns to...
Sorry but that's not correct. The rules says the USSR stops sending a resource if it's aligned to any axis MP. You can avoid losing a res by not aligning it...
Leaving the historic reality aside and just talking in terms of game balance IMO the whole thing is silly. It's certainly worth it for .9 USE, as is Persia,...
Hi, axis declare war on poland :12 FR and CW declare war on Germany : -12 Ussr controls east poland : -7 Ussr declares war on roumania : -18 It seems to me...
Actually Devin the USSR gaining 2 resources and Germany losing 2 (and the Bul units and the time and units needed to retake Bul to regain the res and the route...
it seems you are considering that italian cannot ship ressources because of CW and french forces, but you forget to add the US entry cost of CW declaration of...
Agreed and would further recommend by Michael Gannon both "Operation Drumbeat" and "Black May", which I think is essential, as well as Clay Blair's dual volume...
Not sure what exactly was included in pact. AM sure that it was changed by Stalin and AH got compensated with the 'funny' hex in Poland (farthest east adjacent...
Sorry you snipped out the part you were responding to as I'm not sure that it my comments that would prompt your question. But no I personally do not think...
I did not understand very well what you wanted to say about what has be 'ruled consistently', the only thing I said about china cities is that for china to...
Jeff it actually is a fairly recent change. It was changed in response to the view that an early CH surrender could be too powerfull in terms of USE when you...
Jeff if you think CLiF, CoiF, and FiF is too much asw "bonus" than I fail to understand how you see the RAW change from per 5 to per 2 CP's as better since the...
The problem is not the chit itself, it is that USA will get in the war early, so you need to build up garrison, navy and air power sooner because of these 3...
i believe vichy has to be active to ship resources of or to another mp. in that case, their cps are just as threatened as italys. in the overall + / - resource...
of course the axis can "adjust" to high or low us entry. but if adjusting means stopping attacking a mp, i think its the wrong way to go. harold ... war early,...
Lane, I never intend to say that sub did not use torpedoes, but that, early in the war, they used when possible a mix between torps and deck gun, and against...
... It's determined at the end of the turn, when the resources are actually being transported. -Pat Crowe __________________________________________________ Do...
Does having the US in the war 3 turn earlier, and be oil embargoes 2-3 turn earlier too worth the cost of crushing china? (a minimum for 6 additional chit) ...
You're right of course about hexes not movement points, I had a brain freeze or something. And also right about things that don't stop supply don't stop ...
It's probably dependent on the chits, so could be a "case by case" basis whether it's worth the DOW. FREX, if the US has only 0's or 1's in the Europe pool...
Having problems with message search?
Fill out this form to ensure your group is one of the first to be migrated to the new message search system.
