The first step I would need would be, in terms of WIF CP and sub counters, losses by years for the Axis and Allies in the BoA. Could someone provide me that?...
The question is for pilots in general. Both 13.7.1 and 19.2/19.4 attaches the pilot to the plane, even when it is on the spiral. Thus, when the plane is...
Strike that, reverse it: twice as much in summer vs. winter, duh. As for pre- and post-: because only the advanced ASW gizmo's were good at zonking subs before...
Dave LeLacheur
lelacheur@...
Jul 1, 2004 9:17 am
68097
... A good point to keep in mind. ... The advantage I see is the possibility of flattening out results and making them highly predictable instead of highly...
Dave LeLacheur
lelacheur@...
Jul 1, 2004 9:19 am
68098
... counters, ... baseline result ... I would be more than happy to do this. All I need is the answer to one question: How many subs are in a WiF counter? ...
... Lane, for the record, you did not remotely anger me, and I'm sorry I gave that impression. It was clear that you believed the phrase meant more than 30...
Dave LeLacheur
lelacheur@...
Jul 1, 2004 9:48 am
68100
... it ... and making ... think ... rules ... Ok I can see that. The question is do you want predictable results or an average of results? I'm not entirely...
Thank you. We do have SiF but we've been playing with the CL's all along. So, pull all the old CL's? Chris ... should ... in ... costs ... presorting ... to...
... I gave ... more than ... meant 30, ... don't ... Dave glad you weren't annoyed. However, for Devin or anyone to do thing one on this subject requires we...
... I do indeed have it and do not dispute the linguistics Lane. I simply believe that when it came time for Harry to whip out the spreadsheet, he really used...
Dave LeLacheur
lelacheur@...
Jul 1, 2004 10:08 am
68104
... My first idea: remove sub combat from regular combat sequence. Also: if you include a sub in normal naval combat, it could be required to flip. Then only...
... simply ... spreadsheet, he ... can't prove ... LOL. That's possible. I don't think it's what we should depend on however. How about someone just asks...
... required to ... combat in a ... convoys ... I don't think that is a good idea nor do I think it's possible to make it work with subs doing either or. ...
... I did not say, that subs must be removed from normal combat. I just said that remove the sub combat part, which IMHO reflects how the submarines attack the...
All, I was thinking about Russian partisans and had the following questions. For our purposes, Russia is at war with GE and IT. They have a pact with JA, which...
... Yes, partisans can move inside their own country. ... Yes. ... Yes. This could even be an unofficial part of the USSR/Japanese pact ;-) ... I think it...
This was part of the "problem" to which I was alluding, But it may not be much of a problem at all. It depends how you view the BOA. Should there even be an...
I do not have the rules here, so I will ask. Are those hexes of Siberia that the Japanese now own still part of the Soviet home country? Can partisans attack...
I would argue that partisans can operate in any hex in the '39 home country of its country, so they could cross that "border" into Japan-controlled Siberia. ...
I've been reading this thread with interest. I agree with Lane that any suggested changes should avoid removing subs completely from the normal flow of ...
"Harry states in his designer notes for SiF that it's 30 frontline sub and "more" older types. You can read "more" as additional or more than 30 more. IMO...
Per Harry, the number of subs is exactly 30 per counter. The designer notes are wrong. BTW, my threat to rejigger sub combat is not an idle one. I have a week...
Our group is about to start a new game of WIFFE. Our German player is convinced that there is nothing the Allies can do to effectively defend against a France...
Devin, I have also been thinking SUBS need some reworking, especially with al the new CLiF and COiF counters. One thing I have noticed in researching sub...
What does he mean by France First? Everything on the western front except a few corps screening Poland? Or a 50-50 setup to take out Poland in a turn or two ...
I agree with the below. Putting on the reserves face-down in the first turn really helps the defenders, and not the attackers, in S/O. I think the Germans in...
Germany setup with about 6-7 INF/GAR & 1 HQ-I against Poland. Supporting this, he has 2 LND3 and 1 FTR2. Everything else is on the Belgian/French border....
... not be ... there ... way land ... presence? ... the ... then go ... an ... fine. It ... intercepting ... peaks ... So what happens when the subs are...
Having problems with message search?
Fill out this form to ensure your group is one of the first to be migrated to the new message search system.
