1) HQ only imo. If you want to make another exception for eng: a) houserule or b) ask Harry specifically about eng and voluntary overstacking. The FAQ doesn't...
Hello, About the first question, Harry said that it is not specifical to HQ (asked this morning). But the question is taking the HQ example. Patrice 2009/4/1...
I know that Harry had sent copies to the people who organize the Con, in the days before the Con. I don't know if they used it. Patrice 2009/4/1 paulderynck...
Of course, if you leave Murmansk empty, the Finns will take it regardless of whether you play with the scandinavian map or not. Generally, I prefer to play...
I see what you are saying here Håkon, but I find that if you use the Scandinavian map you will likely never deny a claim on the Finnish borderland because it...
OH MY GOD. Well, I guess NOW I understand the term OVERCOMMITMENT to the Far East. This means HAVING NO ARMY AT ALL in Europe, right? But I'm trying not to add...
Here is the old rule: " Option 50: (USSR-Japan compulsory peace) If Japan controls Vladivostok during the first war between Japan and the USSR, the Japanese...
Rich, I think there was a thread on the list about that when the annual came out - if I recall correctly the way most people interpreted it was your case #1,...
Has it been added to the clarification list and if not can it be? ... From: kenzclark <kenzclark@...> To: wifdiscussion@yahoogroups.com Sent: Wed, 1 Apr...
If you want to look at it as a specific exception then that's consistent, although IMO it's clearly not RAW. I could see a similar exception being made for...
I'm repeating myself, but the answer to Q2.3-1 is not specificaly targeted at HQ. It is a general stacking issue. The Q has it with an HQ for the example. ...
Rich, For what it's worth my group discussed this before our most reccent game and went with interpretation #2. We were of the opinion that if it was #1 the...
I don't have time to be absolutely positive on this by checking it all in the rules, but on this list, the best way to get it right is to wait and see how...
The answer is to a specific question. You can't just widen the application because you feel like it/think that it should be that way. That indeed would be a...
Agree with 2. Hasn't come up yet in our games, we normally play without option 50, aso can't say how the discussion will turn out in the end for our group. ......
Do you need the exact quote from Harry ? Anyway, the question is currently under pending reword so that it is clear that this is not only HQ. Unless I am...
Well, I can only speak for myself, but I've denied the borderland several times, both with and without the Scandinavian map, including in my current game with...
I wonder if your opponents demand the borderlands in M/J '40 or earlier. I find that if you demand them while Germany is in France/Belgium that Germany tends...
This is how I interpret the rule: if Japan takes Vlad (or the USSR takes the 3 resources in Manchuria), you use the old surrender rules that have the limited...
In my current game with Tobias (Super Balbo Challenge, v2), Russia demanded the borderlands in S/O 39. Russia did have a mech vs Petsamo, but no other...
I see this differently: War with Finland will undoubtedly lead to RU victory. GE will undoubtedly need finnish winterised units - unless RU gets completely...
I wouldn't demand the borderlands unless I was ready to make an attack that I thought would give me a hex in finland without getting any flips and in the...
That is certainly a possible interpretation. I think it comes down to 2 things, is the forced peace a surrender by the player forcing it and, if so, is it...
For the current game between me and Hakon, I guess we´ll have to see how it goes. I took Aland, the Finnish island, on an auto-invasion and it is held by a...
How does the sequence of Vichy collapse work out ? On the impulse when the Axis collapses Vichy can 1- An axis transport (laden with troops) sail into a...
Having problems with message search?
Fill out this form to ensure your group is one of the first to be migrated to the new message search system.
