Search the web
Sign In
New User? Sign Up
napoleonic_empires
? Already a member? Sign in to Yahoo!

Yahoo! Groups Tips

Did you know...
Want to share photos of your group with the world? Add a group photo to Flickr.

Best of Y! Groups

   Check them out and nominate your group.
Having problems with message search? Fill out this form to ensure your group is one of the first to be migrated to the new message search system.

Messages

  Messages Help
Advanced
building troops   Message List  
Reply | Forward Message #1684 of 1744 |
Re: building troops

Greetings:

Any answer... to any question, that contains the words "should be"
is suspect and not trustworthy. I do not know who wrote the Q&A in
the rule book but, that one is definitely wrong.

Can you build troops in a newly conquered province? Of course not.
Once your province was taken, and you then took it back, it is a
newly conquered province to you. No troops will be built.
Skip


Adm Barbaros <adm_barbaros@...> wrote:
"Skip and Scotty, i see your point of view but
nap rulebook page 23;
Troops built:
...If your province is attacked, but you successfully defend it,
then you will be able to build troops there....
and page 58;
Q: If I give orders to build troops in a city and an enemy force
takes it in the 1st move-phase and then, in the 2nd move-phase I
take it back (so at the end of the movement, it belongs to me), then
my troops will be build, right? I looked in the rulebook and it says
that if you defend your city, your troops will be built (and I am
sort of defending it :)
A: Yes, they should be built.
adm Barbar os




Fri Nov 7, 2008 12:48 pm

stork1656
Offline Offline
Send Email Send Email

Forward
Message #1684 of 1744 |
Expand Messages Author Sort by Date

I was just wondering. If I order builds at a production center and I temporarily lose possession but still hold the province at the end of the turn...then...
re_lee_2006
Offline Send Email
Nov 6, 2008
10:58 am

Yes Lee...troops will be build. adm barbaros ________________________________ From: re_lee_2006 <re_lee_2006@...> To: napoleonic_empires@yahoogroups.com ...
Adm Barbaros
adm_barbaros
Offline Send Email
Nov 6, 2008
4:29 pm

Greetings: Admiral, I believe that your answer is incorrect. Once a province is lost (for even a single phase) further orders are lost as well. Skip Adm...
stork1656
Offline Send Email
Nov 7, 2008
12:43 am

Not to question you Admiral, but I wondered about that answer my self. I thought that once you had lost a province that, YES all orders would be lost as well....
bob scott
scottydogone23
Offline Send Email
Nov 7, 2008
2:27 am

Skip and Scotty, i see your point of view but nap rulebook page 23; Troops built: ...If your province is attacked, but you successfully defend it, then you...
Adm Barbaros
adm_barbaros
Offline Send Email
Nov 7, 2008
5:17 am

Greetings: Any answer... to any question, that contains the words "should be" is suspect and not trustworthy. I do not know who wrote the Q&A in the rule...
stork1656
Offline Send Email
Nov 7, 2008
12:48 pm

GUYS: That sort of, is what we are talking about?? LOL If you lose the province even for one phase, YOU HAVE LOST IT, now when you retake it, even next phase...
bob scott
scottydogone23
Offline Send Email
Nov 7, 2008
2:39 pm

LOL Gotta love it!! This is a great way for all of us to get A GAME EDUCATION?? Thanks Bob S _____ From: napoleonic_empires@yahoogroups.com ...
bob scott
scottydogone23
Offline Send Email
Nov 7, 2008
2:31 pm

As fortification charts of napoleonic empires and Age of Conquest are wrong, Q/A parts of rulebooks definetely be wrong containing "should". But this is the...
Adm Barbaros
adm_barbaros
Offline Send Email
Nov 7, 2008
3:53 pm
Advanced

Copyright © 2009 Yahoo! Inc. All rights reserved.
Privacy Policy - Terms of Service - Guidelines - Help