Hi Mike, There are many good ideas in your post, and in those submitted by others on this site. Besides, I like it when someone agrees with me– a relative...
I agree that a complete rewrite of the rules is such a big job that it might never happen. As an alternative, and more in line with the availability of time...
... From: Michael Wedding <michaelw989@...> Subject: Good Points To: jriii@yahoogroups.com Date: Friday, August 1, 2008, 7:15 AM My compliments to all of...
... By ... on this site some time ago? > ... Look in the Files. Bob Sweeny did one some time back and it is in with his stuff. I have not been able to...
Paul; ... I spoke to John Hill at the con on this point. He said that it was his intention that units "in the area", on hold could fire at a charging unit, not...
As a newbie I would look forward to buying a revised/expanded JRiii 2nd Edition. Theoretically speaking, I would be even happier to buy a JRBY, but would...
Well, Historicon is now behind us, I hope you all had as much fun as I did! I am almost caught back up on my sleep! Now it is time to turn our thoughts...
We've always played it where hold fires can take place at any time against any unit the firer can target...also, we've never allowed shaken units to add...
Thanks for that PJ. Although not being there at the time when John Hill said this, am i right in thinking that it was "off the top of his head" remark? What ...
Well Jim, 40mm seems to be a standard for 28s. I like the GW bases. Squares allow the column length to look right when turned to a flank. I use 4 indivual...
I am speaking on this topic on Friday night at Fall-In! as one of the guest speakers for the military college portion of the event. I have 90% of the...
Paul, I like the more definitive look between regiments of different strengths. Standardization also makes for more scenario flexiblity with any given pool of...
Doug, I agree with your idea for a new edition of JRIII, as opposed to a JR4.It makes perfect sense to me. IMO what the JRIII concept needs most are...
To elaborate on the thread a bit more. Because I see both 12 fig and 16 fig regiments as straddling the JR regimental mean b/c I see the actual ACW regimental...
... However, ... action ... involving ... Mike Wedding was almost going to bring a Petersburg Crater scenerio to Johnny Con 2. Other things came up and he did...
Somewhat incidentally, with 4 figs per stand, if a return were made to a 40 yard per inch ground scale and the fig per troop ratio remained at 1 to 30, with...
Okay Dan. Thanks. I am encouraged that you agree with the firing protocol I advocate. I'm wondering if you have a rationale for not allowing Shaken units to...
Jerrywrote: However I urge to reconsider your stance of waiting to begin the process of rewriting the rules until current stocks of JRIII rules are deemed...
Scott, I can sent you some pictures of 28mm action. Shall I post them to the group photos or do you want attachments to your address? Paul Stevenson ... ...
Sure Jim, the cavalry are based ewo on a 50mm square. On ave 3 bns x 4 stands each = Fed regt. I also have single figures 25 x 50mm which when placed with a...
I've enlarged my 28mm photo file somewhat. Scott you can see some useful pics for Petersburg and Jim you can see how the units look based. The dinky guns...
Thanks, Paul. I think you've talked me into going with 4 fig stands for JRiii. I still think a theoretical case exists for 3 fig stands, but I think that case...
Lads, Please feel free to send emails that describe the holes and anomalies in the rules. I will work with Doug, and any of the many JRIII experts on this site...
Well Dean, my question is, is defensive support mandatory when a potential support unit is not an object of a charge and is within 2'' of the charge target ?...
This is great news Dean! Thank you for taking this on. I certainly hope several of the other JRIII experts aid you in this effort. My personal experience would...
Jim, I hope for much input on the charge issues, then we will codify/qmpliphy/clarify- whatever it takes. We do not want to alter JRIII. I see the mission...
Here's a suggestion w/ another idea on the recently discussed "beating the BMP" rule. Order Definition & Effect, pg. 34 Hold "Holding units will always fire...
Having problems with message search?
Fill out this form to ensure your group is one of the first to be migrated to the new message search system.
