... As some have said, 'some times the Axis shoudl win'. But, IMO, the Axis should win because they win, not because of an unintended consequence of a rule...
... You may be correct that the 'effective' BRP base for calculating the construction limit is only 35. But, IMO, the contribution to the British construction...
Correct, I should have said, British BRP base **minus uncontrolled KEA's**, minus Commonwealth Base [Or IC's] is zero or less. Just like 39.22 states: 39.22...
Same here! ULTRA is one of the best vehicles for learning nuances in the game. Especially now that the rules have settled, I wonder if some previous ULTRA...
I've subscribed to five more years of Ultra. Maurice's email in my inbox is a very welcome one. Moreover, I think Ultra not only helps the current group of...
... early ... most 'fragile' ... level of ... base, but not with his conclusion that something is wrong with the rules. I think that the rules simulate the...
I think you're jumping to a conclusion, though, Don. While the Axis may certainly win this game, it is only Su42. There are three more years for the US to...
... Ah, that makes sense. It is certainly consistent with the other "Commonweath BRPs are protected" rules. While the rules don't currently say that, it...
... I agree with this. I certainly don't know that the Axis have one yet. Russia has not been attacked and is starting to look pretty scary. It is not very...
The answers to these questions are fairly simple and no rule changes are required to deal with the rare situation which came up this game, 40 BRPs of the...
Bruce Harper
bruce54321@...
Dec 1, 2006 3:31 pm
97943
I am going to rework my question and provide what I believe the answer is (with relevant rules). Hopefully this will help others and allow me to check my...
Robin: yes it ends, because the whole section 51.22 is entitles as "Prewar Restrictions" which would not end when tensions reach 50 but when war starts. ... ...
... I agree with this. If the BRPs contributed to the British base by the Commonwealth cannot be lost (other than by Indian or Australian surrenders), then...
... Any issue that you write an article for, you get for free... ;) Let me take this opportunity again to remind subscribers to check their subscription status...
What is the range for the Murmansk box to Casablanca? German units in Murmansk want to base change there (remaining uninverted as per 21.224) and do so by...
You can't base change from the Murmansk box to Casablanca - only to Bergen, Oslo or Scapa Flow. 5.87 GROUND AND AIR UNITS: A. MOVEMENT: Ground units may not...
Mike Crowe
mcrowe@...
Dec 2, 2006 1:19 pm
97953
I greatly enjoyed the Summer 2006 Ultra. Using the Fuhreer Diretive as a framework for the discusion was an inspired idea. I throw out these observations about...
Another view is that it very difficult for the Axis to accomplish any of this and that if the Axis manage it, the British should suffer instead of getting a...
Bruce Harper
bruce54321@...
Dec 2, 2006 4:50 pm
97955
Another defensive possibility... Does anyone ever move 1 sub to the Isles for the fall turn? One extra sub an be very inconvenient against an invasion already...
... I have (and have seen other players) place one or both British subs in southern England for such use. And, after US entry, when the fighting on the home...
... Personally, I find it a higher priority to keep up with DD construction in the early game. Then once the subs get going, the British are straining to build...
... Subs no longer count against the 'light' shipbuilding limit: 27.7221 DESTROYERS, CVEs, ASW AND TRANSPORTS: A. Each turn no more than half (round up) of...
But recall that subs no longer count against the limit on light shipbuilding (and the light shipbuilding limit now applies to all major powers - not just the...
... I would agree. When I play the Allies, I usually have less. When I play the Axis, I usually see less. ... This is correct - and Britain producing a 3-4 in...
... given. ... fort in 1940 is indispensible. If I have to choose, I will opt for the 3-4. If the military breakthrough is achieved in 1939 or a sure thing in...
The article did not attempt to analyze the British defence in 1940 in any detail. ... From: donmoody@... To: aworldatwar@yahoogroups.com Sent: Saturday,...
Having problems with message search?
Fill out this form to ensure your group is one of the first to be migrated to the new message search system.
