I agree with Bruce's proposal to (a) abolish the +4 Poland + -5 EEurope modifiers, and (b) prohibit Russian DP from being allocated to Russia. With respect to...
8513
Michael Stone
71051.1037@xxxxxxxxxx...
Dec 1, 1999 9:47 am
... One possible theoretical anomaly here is the *possible* "overabstraction" of transports under the current oil rules. As it currently stands, oil is the...
8514
Michael Stone
71051.1037@xxxxxxxxxx...
Dec 1, 1999 10:01 am
From: Martin Smith ... No, it's your style of play which does that... ... (Please note that this is a textbook example of the pot calling the kettle black...)...
8515
Darren_Kilfara@xxxx.xxx
Dec 1, 1999 10:04 am
... offensive ... seems ... No, actually this modifier was instituted to prevent Germany from attritioning Poland to death over two turns (saving offensive...
8516
Stephen Ede
S.Ede@...
Dec 1, 1999 12:22 pm
Darren, I find your comment interesting, as my opponent in one of the games I'm playing at the moment used a setup that I struggled to get a 3:1 vs Warsaw, and...
8517
Darren_Kilfara@xxxx.xxx
Dec 1, 1999 12:28 pm
... I'm ... Warsaw, and ... was a ... can ... Bruce or others may come howling down upon me if I'm wrong, but I'm 99% certain that a "correct" German opening...
8518
Martin Smith
mcs@xx.xx.xx.xxx
Dec 1, 1999 12:43 pm
Can someone help explain 37.7 to me? Does the Russian player have to decide to use an IC as an unlimited supply source in the initial supply determination...
8519
Stephen Ede
S.Ede@xxx.xxx.xxx
Dec 1, 1999 12:51 pm
Darren, Here you are,the Polish setup. L35 1-3, L36 1-3, M35 2-3, 2-3, M36 1-3, N34 1-3, N35 1-3, 2-3, N36 1-3, O35 1-3, Stephen Ede <Bruce or others may come...
8520
Mark Yaeger
myaeger@xxxxxx.xx.xxxx
Dec 1, 1999 1:21 pm
Poland can be setup to prevent two 3:1 attacks... but can't be setup to prevent two 2.5:1 attacks... which will still be automatically successful now with the...
8521
Edward John Schoenfeld
ejschoenfeld@xxxxxxxx...
Dec 1, 1999 2:14 pm
Michael Stone wrote ... Japan must have 1 transport for every 20 Brps of overseas conquests Britain receives 25 Brps from colonies on the European map. In...
8522
bruce_h@xxxxx.xxxxxxx...
bruce_h@xxxxx.xxxxxxx...
Dec 1, 1999 3:47 pm
... After reading Don's posting, I added the bit at the end (I tried to compact the oil effects into a single paragraph so they will fit on the oil cards. I...
8523
bruce_h@xxxxx.xxxxxxx...
bruce_h@xxxxx.xxxxxxx...
Dec 1, 1999 3:58 pm
... [Proposed solution...} ... No. If we really wanted a rule like this, and I can't recall why we would, the only simple solution I can see is to tie British...
8524
bruce_h@xxxxx.xxxxxxx...
bruce_h@xxxxx.xxxxxxx...
Dec 1, 1999 3:59 pm
I think the solution to this wrinkle is that partial supply is good enough for airbases and bridgeheads. ... Bruce Harper...
8525
Martin Smith
mcs@xx.xx.xx.xxx
Dec 1, 1999 3:04 pm
... This seems a bit fiddly, and I'm not sure what situation it is supposed to cover. It would be simpler to say that naval units under an oil effect can't...
8526
Leith.Keven@xxxxxxx.xxx
Dec 1, 1999 4:36 pm
Ed wrote (in relation to WA transports and British BRPs ... And Bruce replied; ... Well, as a former suggestor of something similar, I mention that a potential...
8527
Martin Smith
mcs@xx.xx.xx.xxx
Dec 1, 1999 6:34 pm
... Couldn't this reduce the submarine defense level of the naval force, since only operational carriers (i.e., those with their full complement of naf) count...
8528
DonMoody
DonMoody@xxxxxx.xxxx
Dec 1, 1999 8:09 pm
With regards to Polish survival viability, I shall make the unequivocal statement that, provided the Germans are willing to commit the forces necessary, there...
8529
Stephen Ede
S.Ede@xxx.xxx.xxx
Dec 1, 1999 8:57 pm
Mark, Do these all work if you roll exchanges on all the overuns. Stephen From: "Mark Yaeger" <myaeger@...> Poland can be setup to prevent two 3:1...
8530
GregLWilson@xxxxxxxx....
Dec 1, 1999 9:14 pm
... From: Michael Stone <71051.1037@...> ... I have only one short comment to say about the above exchange. Who are you!!! And what have you done to...
8531
Stephen Ede
S.Ede@xxx.xxx.xxx
Dec 1, 1999 9:37 pm
Don, Thank you, you're obviously much smarter than me, but, I did notice you made one little mistake. It doesn't change the result, but, when the German Air ...
8532
Greg Wilson
GregLWilson@xxxxxxxx....
Dec 1, 1999 3:15 pm
... From: Michael Stone <71051.1037@...> ... I have only one short comment to say about the above exchange. Who are you!!! And what have you done to...
8533
Matt McKrell ...
mckrell@xxxx.xxx.xxxx
Dec 1, 1999 10:07 pm
I have an additional question that came up in my current playtest game concerning sub warfare results. Lets say that 4 subs survive the ASW, with a +2 mod,...
8534
Stephen Ede
S.Ede@xxx.xxx.xxx
Dec 1, 1999 11:22 pm
Bruce, If 5 AAF start on a hex, can you during the SR phase, SR all 5 to a location, drop of 2 factors and continue SRing the remaining 3 factors to another...
8535
Markus Kaessbohrer
MarkusK@xxx.xxx.xxxx
Dec 1, 1999 10:49 pm
On 1 Dec 99, Michael Stone gave me the pleasure of reading (on ... Simplest would be something like "if at the end of a turn, there are less than 15...
8536
Larry Torrance
gwgamer@xxxxxxx.xxxx
Dec 2, 1999 2:19 am
Turkey no longer has 2 armor units - only one now. Cheers, Larry Torrance...
8537
Larry Torrance
gwgamer@xxxxxxx.xxxx
Dec 2, 1999 2:25 am
A well-set Polish defense can prevent all 3on1's, however, the Germans can gaurentee conquest with at least 2 and 1/2 on 1's or better. Cheers, Larry Torrance...
8538
GregSonia8@xxx.xxx
Dec 2, 1999 2:43 am
In a message dated 12/1/99 12:42:41 AM Central Standard Time, ... I appoligize if I offended you. I did not mean to do so I was just making a joking type of...
8539
DonMoody
DonMoody@xxxxxx.xxxx
Dec 2, 1999 5:11 am
... Here is the relevant rule from the latest playtest download: 19.3 AIR COMBAT MODIFIERS: 19.31 MODIFIERS: Each side’s air combat dice roll is subject...
8540
bruce_h@xxxxx.xxxxxxx...
bruce_h@xxxxx.xxxxxxx...
Dec 2, 1999 6:15 am
It covers the situation where Britain is subject to an oil effect and wants to keep naval units in Britain for other reasons (such as intercepting a German...
8541
bruce_h@xxxxx.xxxxxxx...
bruce_h@xxxxx.xxxxxxx...
Dec 2, 1999 6:15 am
... You better get (re)reading them (again). You might want to start with 19.31A. ... Bruce Harper...
