... Works for me. I hope the newer players now understand why the design process generated 70000+ emails. Ed ... declare war on Vichy ... Either side may ... ...
As usual, you have been able to get to the heart of the issues, and weave together the best of the proposals. This is great, and fair to all. Eric Laner Date:...
Laner, Eric (CMS.JAX)
eric_laner@...
Apr 1, 2004 2:18 pm
65491
This may have gotten lost in the midst of the Vichy kerfuffle: According to 40.48 (see below), Western Allied naval units return to the port or mapboard box of...
... I might be missing something. Doesn't this prohibit Germany from attacking Vichy colonies until US Germany are at war and wouldn't that limit there...
BRAINDAMA@... wrote: [from Bruce's proposal] ... What you are missing is if the Axis want to do as you suggest, they must not establish Vichy France. ...
Dear Group, I think that prohibiting a DOW against Vichy until a fixed time(US and Germany at war) will lead to a lot of games where Vichy is not formed at...
No - what Vic is missing is that if the Axis want to do this, they must persuade Vichy to allow them to, by making a diplomatic die roll. So you have to go...
Bruce Harper
bruce54321@...
Apr 1, 2004 3:36 pm
65497
You are implying that the Vichy French units in the colonies are treated as "neutral" during the Axis movement phase, and that Axis units can move over and...
Mike Crowe
mcrowe@...
Apr 1, 2004 4:36 pm
65498
Britain historically attacked Syria before us entry. Its unclear whether you can still dow the colonies one at a time and whether you can dow colonies before...
... No its not. The only change is to 77.5 The rest of 77 is unchanged. For example, these are unchanged: 77.6 ATTACKING VICHY FRENCH COLONIES: 77.61 NO...
correct Don, so why would Germany now ever establish Vichy? If it does, Allies attack each colony with only a reaction roll risk (net -1 if yaken out in one...
for the same reason as now, not to give Britain extra units. those other effects are secondary. I am fine with bruces proposal. (although I still prefer...
... Because the EuroAxis are nor pursuing a Med strategy? ... Only the ones which don't go Free French. ... What is the EuroAxis plan? Why would you chose to...
ok, so you say that if Axis are pursuing a med strategy they will likely need to not establish Vichy. So if Axis are not pursuing a med strategy. Which is now...
I can see alot of people just not establishing Vichy so not to bother with this. It is one less diplomacy target to defend, and if all the colonies go FF so ...
Eric: if Vichy is not established, colonies that would have gone Vichy go independent instead. Then would require a DoW costing 10brp vs each. yes, no change...
Gotcha - my mistake. Eric Thobaben ... From: Maurice Miskow [mailto:miskow@...] Eric: if Vichy is not established, colonies that would have gone Vichy...
"A World at War" MAILING LIST INFO List/Website Administrator: Paul Stoecker, DonMoody Email: aworldatwar-owner@yahoogroups.com Official AWAW Website:...
aworldatwar@yahoogrou...
Apr 2, 2004 12:22 am
65509
Greetings! This monthly information message for the "A World At War" mailing lists explains the: QUESTION & ANSWER PROTOCOL How do I ask a question? a. Check...
aworldatwar@yahoogrou...
Apr 2, 2004 12:22 am
65510
... to the port or mapboard box of origin of a Murmansk convoy "after resolving any opposition". There is no exception for units which ... to the place where...
I was not able to read every single Vichy post but I think that I caught most of them. I have nothing to add to Bruce`s most recent proposed rulings except to...
I think by the time Germany DoWs Vichy, it would be because the Allies are too, so it would be a wash, So I don't think any additional diplomatic penalty is...
Bruce Harper
bruce54321@...
Apr 2, 2004 7:16 am
65513
Consistency (April 30, 2004): 40.48 DISPOSITION OF UNITS AFTER COMBAT: After resolving any opposition to a Murmansk convoy: ... C. WESTERN ALLIED NAVAL...
Bruce Harper
bruce54321@...
Apr 2, 2004 6:46 pm
65514
situation: defender flies 2AAF from same base to provide DAS, attacker intercepts with AAF and NAS, after air combat using all AAS, the attacker achieves a 1/3...
... Defender loses 1 AAS of his choice and has 1 of each type of AAS aborted (i.e. inverted). This leaves 2 uninverted AAS which are insufficient to become 1 ...
Having problems with message search?
Fill out this form to ensure your group is one of the first to be migrated to the new message search system.
