... Just a small comment on this: other units which are isolated at the time of their demise (whether behind enemy lines or garrisoning a bastion like ...
4605
ejschoenfeld@xxxxxxxx...
ejschoenfeld@xxxxxxxx...
Jun 1, 1999 2:05 pm
... The relavent rules exist in part because Ethiopian forces in A3R were part of a variant and in excess of the force pool levels designed to provide a ...
4606
bruce_h@xxxxx.xxxxxxx...
bruce_h@xxxxx.xxxxxxx...
Jun 1, 1999 2:49 pm
Are you *still* going on about that?! The rule has been changed (I hope you didn't miss it) and you should be able to adjust the USN accordingly. ... Bruce...
4607
kozan@xxxxxxxxxxx.xxx...
kozan@xxxxxxxxxxx.xxx...
Jun 1, 1999 3:56 pm
... I assume the need for carriers to make ASW modifiers operational would also apply to Japan for consistency. That may place Japan in a very hard position....
4608
kozan@xxxxxxxxxxx.xxx...
kozan@xxxxxxxxxxx.xxx...
Jun 1, 1999 3:58 pm
Hello, Has there been a recent (2-3 months) change in the naval construction table at start positions for Rosyth? Kozan Soykal...
4609
Laner, Eric (PCF - NJ)
ELaner@xxx.xx.xx.xxxx
Jun 1, 1999 4:54 pm
I was thinking JUST CVs, not 3ff BB. Eric...
4610
bruce_h@xxxxx.xxxxxxx...
bruce_h@xxxxx.xxxxxxx...
Jun 2, 1999 12:52 am
Not that I know of. ... Bruce Harper...
4611
Markus Kaessbohrer
MarkusK@xxx.xxx.xxxx
Jun 2, 1999 1:09 am
On 31 May 99, Bruce Harper gave me the pleasure of reading (on Re: ... Courageous actually was, doctrinally correct, returning from a hunter-killer anti-sub...
4612
Markus Kaessbohrer
MarkusK@xxx.xxx.xxxx
Jun 2, 1999 1:09 am
On 1 Jun 99, Edward J Schoenfeld gave me the pleasure of reading (on ... There are two extremes - either the pockets were not completely closed (Falaise,...
4613
John Barone
spot.barone@xxxxxxxx....
Jun 2, 1999 1:18 am
This is a very interesting idea, and very historical (the Allies couldn't really beat the subs until the closed the "air gap" with escort carriers.). I have a...
4614
bruce_h@xxxxx.xxxxxxx...
bruce_h@xxxxx.xxxxxxx...
Jun 2, 1999 1:11 am
Actually the requirement *wouldn't* apply - that's why I used the phrase "oceanic SW boxes", which means the Atlantic, Pacific and Indian Ocean SW boxes, but...
4615
bruce_h@xxxxx.xxxxxxx...
bruce_h@xxxxx.xxxxxxx...
Jun 2, 1999 1:18 am
What does it matter whether you remove three Italian infantry or one Italian AAF? Either way, you can use the Italian Fall 1939 mobilization to generate the...
4616
bruce_h@xxxxx.xxxxxxx...
bruce_h@xxxxx.xxxxxxx...
Jun 2, 1999 1:37 am
Long ago and far away, Dave Casper wanted to include Iceland and the Azores as sub war modifiers, the use of which would be related to German occupation of...
4617
bruce_h@xxxxx.xxxxxxx...
bruce_h@xxxxx.xxxxxxx...
Jun 2, 1999 1:44 am
Another thought - should the British be allowed to build CVEs? I think they did, although not nearly as many as the Americans. If the requirement was that one...
4618
John Barone
spot.barone@xxxxxxxx....
Jun 2, 1999 2:00 am
Thanks for bringing me up to speed on what had been discussed before. I didn't realize that such a modifier had been discussed before. In regards to the...
4619
bruce_h@xxxxx.xxxxxxx...
bruce_h@xxxxx.xxxxxxx...
Jun 2, 1999 2:00 am
Raeder wanted to occupy a lot of things! We should keep these possibilities in mind as we consider the options for carriers and ASW. ... Bruce Harper...
4620
William F Steiner
110652.1220@xxxxxxxxx...
Jun 2, 1999 2:47 am
Message text written by INTERNET:gw2k@onelist.com ... you ... Well, Greg hasn't quite agreed to retroactively adjust the USN....especially since 18 naf's just...
4621
bruce_h@xxxxx.xxxxxxx...
bruce_h@xxxxx.xxxxxxx...
Jun 2, 1999 2:50 am
Since there's nothing I can do which would cause the change to have been made sooner, there's not much else I can say. It might be worth rolling back your...
4622
CroweMike@xxx.xxx
Jun 2, 1999 3:42 am
In a message dated 6/1/99 8:59:48 PM Eastern Daylight Time, ... An interesting point. Perhaps we should just disallow fleet carriers from participating in...
4623
ejschoenfeld@xxxxxxxx...
ejschoenfeld@xxxxxxxx...
Jun 2, 1999 4:36 am
Bruce replied to me ... The only point here is what the Italians have available from fa39-Fa40, and what it takes to replace the units (i.e. it is a matter of...
4624
ejschoenfeld@xxxxxxxx...
ejschoenfeld@xxxxxxxx...
Jun 2, 1999 4:36 am
... This is plausible and might be fun ... I am not sure this is a wise idea. By late 1941, Britain will have 10 or so ASW in the box. REQUIRING that they...
4625
William F Steiner
110652.1220@xxxxxxxxx...
Jun 2, 1999 4:49 am
... force). No. I only lost 3 antiquated Japanese Battleships. The Japanese carriers were busy that turn sinking the Valiant and Prince of Wales off ...
4626
Bruce Harper
bruce_h@...
Jun 2, 1999 1:05 pm
I don't think there really was a vote, but this is good enough for me! ... Japanese ... Bruce Harper...
4627
Greg Wilson
GregLWilson@xxxxxxxx....
Jun 2, 1999 1:33 pm
Well , maybe I should pipe in a little here. ... I have not said I would not roll back, I just have to figure it out still. The 8 Carriers have not all been...
4628
Laner, Eric (PCF - NJ)
ELaner@xxx.xx.xx.xxxx
Jun 2, 1999 1:42 pm
I think Ed said a mouthful (on all points). I second his conclusions. Eric PS. I too think Iceland should be added as an Allied modifier...
4629
William F Steiner
110652.1220@xxxxxxxxx...
Jun 2, 1999 1:49 pm
... Arrgg....the dreaded 1 -1 result rears its ugly head....three panzer corps die in the attack and several more die isolated in the Crimea.... So much for...
4630
Michael Stone
71051.1037@xxxxxxxxxx...
Jun 2, 1999 2:59 pm
... Perhaps I'm just being Dumb In Public [again], but I fail to see the difference between requiring a NAF rebuild point to build a CVE versus...
4631
Francis.Timothy
Francis.Timothy@xxx.x...
Jun 2, 1999 3:00 pm
... The hardcore historian should realize it was the "two-ocean navy" legislation of summer 1940 (in response to the fall of France) that led to the vast new...
4632
Patrick Q. Mullen
pmullen@xxxxxx.xx.xxx...
Jun 2, 1999 3:10 pm
... Ahhhh, but *that* is my point exactly. The Two Ocean Navy Legislation *emphasized* BB Construction. USN Doctrinal Opinion on Building CV's was Greatly ...
4633
Patrick Q. Mullen
pmullen@xxxxxx.xx.xxx...
Jun 2, 1999 4:03 pm
A Quick Question: Does the Repair of CA's count Torwards SB Rate and Capacity ? Pat "Always presume that the enemy has dangerous designs and always be...
