Ed, I'll take your word for it. The distinction between a TF and a combat group seems odd, but it doesn't appear to make any practical difference. Thanks,...
I apologize is this question has already been asked and answered, but I was wondering if after a GB surrender/US separate peace if the US can STILL grant...
... The US must be at war with Germany to grante BRPs to Russia. I think the rule you need is: 40.333 POST-ELECTION GRANTS: An election result of -6 or below...
THANK-YOU Randy! It was silly of me to miss that later rule. Please forgive the additional follow-on question. Can I assume that the restriction on BRP...
... Yes. Shipping an oil counter is the same as shipping 10 BRPs. If you can't ship 10 BRPs, you can't ship an oil counter. I have to admit that if Germany...
Hi SItuation Axis make attrition 51+ in the west front against allies forces. At the start of the axis player turn, all was a single att zone However, one...
No, unless you have a very strange situation! From what you describe, the Allies are in France in force, with one armored unit that you surrounded. So all...
Dear all, Peter Bäckgren (Eskimo) is not on the list, but have the following question. In Summer-41 the Axis invade U41 and place a bridgehead (BH) there. In ...
... Correct. (That air-range is operational range of army air factors and is not modified by air-range results.) ... Such future events have no effect, when...
It seems to me you can argue that removal of the bridgehead worsens the supply situation, in general. Also, I don't think you should be forced to remove a...
... 1) Removal of a BH in the turn of placement is common; e.g. most invasions of small islands - and any invasion of a one hex island - will result in removal...
Were these rules finalized? Also, will the final revisions make it to the AWorldAtWar.com site? The South Bend minicon is rapidly approaching, and the players...
I think Dons point is that the rules are pretty clear that the BH is removed. You argument seems to be more that you think it should say that it should take...
I asked this same question (about a bridgehead in N. Turkey) about a month or two ago. Several people answered just as Don has this time. Bruce Wallace ... ...
Bill, Well, I never would have interpreted the rule to say that you should remove a bridgehead in the turn of placement. Automatically removing them from one...
I think both Peter and me agree with Mike, as well as Don. The current rule is rather clear except possibly for the "worsen the supply situation (31.4).",...
I've never found this rule difficult to interpret and it has been like this for a long time, so someone would have to come up with a better formulation. Keep...
Bruce Harper
bruce54321@...
Mar 7, 2008 3:45 pm
109645
Jan-Erik Wahlund wrote ... FWIW, overstacking is not a supply issue, so is not a factor in applying 31.41C: 31.41 REMOVAL COMPULSORY: A bridgehead counter must...
... like this for a long time, so someone would have to come up with a better formulation. Agreed ... counters (I think) and they were limited in number,...
On 7 Mar 2008/10:49, Jan-Erik Wahlund gave me the pleasure of reading (Re: ... Which errors? I am smiling about your progress both in understanding the game...
On 7 Mar 2008/18:01, Ed Schoenfeld gave me the pleasure of reading ([aworldatwar] Re: ... Precisely. Note that removal occurs at the end of the owning player's...
... This seems odd (to say the least). I suggest this (from the official player turn SoP): 11. Voluntary elimination of units. 12. Uninvert air and naval...
I have been struggling with this game off and on trying to get the rules down. However, it sure seems to me that a simplified version of the rules could be put...
... Did you mean this rule: 12.21 Stacking limits may not be voluntarily exceeded other than as specifically permitted by the rules. Since the rules do not...
Hello Sean Short answer to your question: No, not really. But some decent shortcuts exist. For example, the Sequence of Play guides you in knowing where each...
... This isn't allowed, according to 31.52 EFFECTS OF BRIDGEHEAD REMOVAL: Any ground units overstacked at the end of the owner's player turn as a result of the...
Dang, that would havebeen helpful. Well thanks for the tips, I got barbarossa with air and ground combat down well but am now working on getting the naval...
Having problems with message search?
Fill out this form to ensure your group is one of the first to be migrated to the new message search system.
