... wrote: I agree with Eric's post except for one thing. It would be better to do the project on line. If it is transparent, it will attract more interest and...
On 30 Sep 2007/10:17, Eric Thobaben gave me the pleasure of reading ([aworldatwar] WA ... Ed and I have (re)started doing this (we'd originally started it...
here is rule regarding when research results are revealed: 41.53 REVEALING RESEARCH RESULTS: General research results are never revealed. Other research...
Mike is correct. The CTL increase 'affects play' the first time any activity that is modifier by CTL takes place. In your game, that is at the Axis spring...
A question rises in a current game: Can a partisan counter being used like and together with infantry be voluntarily taken as an attrition loss? Rule 11.45...
... I don't think so. The reason is that 14.52C limits the number of counters that may be lost by nationality. I think that partisans count as their own...
Any opinions? ... Syracuse. ... know ... forces ... were ... as ... the ... the ... interception ... of ... naval ... interceptions ... its ... failed ... ...
... No. The phrase: "Partisans do not participate in attrition combat" is as clear as it gets. Partisans may not participate in attrition in *any* way. I would...
... Thanks Don! That was my guess, but what rules support this? This falls (for me anyway) into the confusing part of the naval rules. The best I have been...
... Let's look at what is being asked. TF1 intercepts. TF1 is counter-intercepted but not in the interception hex. TF2 counter-counter-intercepts in the...
... from the ... Clearly if the two CGs could have combined and didn't, the rules that apply to two TFs still apply. It would make logical sense that the same...
A naval unit changes base from South Africa to Britain. 21.217B allows it to move off-board for most of the distance. However, does it have to enter one...
Thank you Don. Supposed that yours was the correct answer... donmoody@... wrote: ... No. The phrase: "Partisans do not participate in attrition combat"...
... board ... enter ... I do not understand this question. What map hexes would the unit enter when leaving from the South Africa box? If the naval unit is in...
On 2 Oct 2007/13:12, Ed Schoenfeld gave me the pleasure of reading ([aworldatwar] Re: ... OK, this is the one. 5.38 would have said that a unit moves out of...
So the underlying principle is that when naval forces participate together in naval combat (whether or not they actually combine in fleet combat), after combat...
Doesn't rule 22.281A specifically address this issue? It states that when supporting forces join a battle that is eventually won by their side, the victorious...
... No. Rule 22.28 (and its sub-sections) apply to mutual support. The game situation described does not involve mutual support. Here is the game situation...
... boxes ... a ... on- ... I'm glad you are happy with the answer, but you still seem to want 5.38 to apply to a situation(base change from South Africa to...
On 3 Oct 2007/12:51, Ed Schoenfeld gave me the pleasure of reading ([aworldatwar] Re: ... Ah, that's "on" rather than "or" the southern edge of the EU...
Situation: 11 NAS are sitting on carriers in a TF in Rabaul. During movement, they are counteraired, resulting in 2 inverted NAS. This same TF intercepts a...
Answer: a firm "maybe" and "it depends". The independent element is this: does the players whose forces attack Lae counterair Lae, or not? If he does, then...
... element is this: does the players whose forces attack Lae counterair Lae, or not? ... but strike against naval units only, then the inverted NAS do not ...
... box is traced ... or Abadan ... mapboard. ... mapboard... ... How does that make a difference? There is no 'or' because this rule has NOTHING to do with...
On 3 Oct 2007/20:24, Christopher Goldfarb gave me the pleasure of reading ([aworldatwar] ... This by the way is the continuation of my earlier (so far...
the rule says that the carrier is inverted "if the inverted NAS is transferred to the carrier"; but the NAS are based on the carrier while in port, and only...
Having problems with message search?
Fill out this form to ensure your group is one of the first to be migrated to the new message search system.
