So lets talk about comp rules. The comp for the latest CoC are, I feel, way out of balance. Taking a comp hit for having more than 3 ap2 weapons in an 1850...
I thought I remembered (probably somewhere around CoC #2) that the comp had been "scaled" for the 1250 points for that tournament. I might be wrong. I'd have...
Ok, here are a few questions from the current comp list: 1. Why 50% of the points on troops? Why not 45? 50% is HUGE. 2. Can the infiltrating % be changed...
... 40% was the standard for a long time, both in GW sanctioned and indy events. Im not a fan of being penalised for having 'only' 40% troops, but this is not...
... They're searching for the Holy Grail: A comp system everybody can live with. Haven't ever seen one myself. At which point, you just kinda have to say "why...
Well, as I've read all your posts so far I would like to say that I don't agree with all the comp ideas for CP, but that said, I will enjoy playing anyway. The...
... Oh yes. I always enjoy playing, rather than not, and I did have fun last year. ... I agree. Anybody who takes on running a tourney is immune to criticism ...
Hey Guys, I am not ignoring the debate on comp, I am simply not going to get caught up in the debate like last year. I will pay attention to concerns and make...
Great. Thanks Gary. First - I'm going to play, comp or not, and I'm going to try and tailor my army to the comp of the moment, choosing to ignore comp where...
Gary, My thoughts are simply, Why do gaming groups try to set comp systems when GW does many many years of play testing. The game is very balanced. You can...
_____ From: SacCapitalPunishment@yahoogroups.com [mailto:SacCapitalPunishment@yahoogroups.com] On Behalf Of Damon Davies Gary, My thoughts are simply, Why do...
... I agree, Tim, but I have seen NO comp system that corrects this. They just move the base line around from one army to another. ... And I think the current...
i think yes it is a good idea to try something but.. i think in my opinion that the same people are gonna win as usual no matter what way comp is due to the...
_____ From: SacCapitalPunishment@yahoogroups.com [mailto:SacCapitalPunishment@yahoogroups.com] On Behalf Of Steve Fox With regard to madness and confusion, my...
It doesn't look to me like the majority feel that the comp is terrible... just that a few things need to be loostened up to allow more flexibility in the army...
Gary, My thoughts are simply, Why do gaming groups try to set comp systems when GW does many many years of play testing. The game is very balanced. ... Damon,...
... Here's one to ponder, Gary. Last year, my Tau scored a 26 out of 30 in that comp system (86.7%), and went 3-2-0. Not exactly an overpowering record. That...
Tim as I say again, If I run IG and beat up on Tau and orcs then turn around and lose to the Eldar and MArines, which by the way happens quite often, then I am...
In my opinion and only my opinion: 0-10 = Fugly army - rebuild. 11-20 = Ugly tournament "win at any cost and wo gives a damn about my opponent's fun" army OR...
... You missed something, Tim. My army last year scored 87% of the comp points. This year it would score 50%. Why did my army go from well-comped to sucko? I...
Obviously I misread your original e-mail or it was written so as to be easily misread. My opologies. Since you've degenerated into insults I am done with this...
Don't sweat the rending comp question as it is going to be altered significantly, or more likely, dropped. Gary Allan <bobothefool@...> wrote: How many...
MAMAHAHAHAHAHAHAA, I have created the perfect army for this years CP. I shall roll over the competition with my perfect comp army. Yes you read that...
Perfect as in "Great Comp Score" or perfect as in "who care's about comp"? You know the old theory... an army that got perfect comp score was never combat...
Thats a big 50! baby, All the Comp with none of the fat. Yep It's a Beautiful thing. And, so far, in 8 games I have 6 wins, 1 draw, 1 lose to a way over the...
Yikes... the closer to 50 I get on that comp list the worse the army plays against non-50 point armies. Sisters.... that might be the list that can actually...
Doc, Wwhats the GEG July 29th?Damon __________________________________________________ Do You Yahoo!? Tired of spam? Yahoo! Mail has the best spam protection...
Having problems with message search?
Fill out this form to ensure your group is one of the first to be migrated to the new message search system.
