---"Tony Sorrentino" <rules.lawyer@v...> wrote:
> <snip>
> Okay, could you explain to me why #17 can work, but #36 does not.
> Based on the clarified ruling on how "As", "When/Whenever"
> and "Immediately after" work how can this be? In #36, the Frusk
> has to wait for the TQ to resolve before its Effect is triggered.
> By that time it's too late because the Frusk is no longer in play.
> In #17, The Great Throne Mushrooms gets discarded when the
> Cataclysm is resolved. How can you use its Effect if it's no
> longer in play? Both cards say "Whenever".

Whoops. :) The timing words ruling was one of the last rulings we
finalized for this digest. I thought we'd caught all of the rulings
it applied to in this monster of a digest, sorry about that. Good
catch.

Tony is indeed correct... The Great Throne Mushrooms trigger
Whenever, which in the case of Cataclysm is AFTER the cataclysm
resolves. Therefore, you get NO card draw from GTM after a
cataclysm.

-Rich Riley
Redeemer of Ogar
Magi Nation DUEL Rules Team