Hello everyone. A karama card can be great in the right situation...but in general...here's my "best to worst". How close is this to your ranking? Which...
I would need to spend more time to work out a full top twenty list but I would definately have used #18 & #19 & #20 a lot more than several others. #18 Having...
... x Harkonnen "(MVP) - swap treachery cards (a momentum breaker...truly ... combo)" x. Any - Cancel BG Voice[#7 x BG - Use any worthless as a karama card...
... Good for marginal game win attempts. ... Good as a terrorist threat. I think I snarfed up three turns worth of spice blows just by threatening to use the...
... I'd rank these ones much more highly ... - very powerful, especially when you are fighting multiple battles in a round, and need to be as efficient as...
... <snip> ... Tom, Do you play that a single karama prevents Atreides from seeing all Treachery cards during that bidding round? I assumed it only prevented...
I think that technically, its worded "Prevent the Atreides from seeing the rest of the cards up for the round", so if you bought it with card 1 purchase, you...
... the "Bidding Phase". the whole thing ... Would that also apply to negating Atreides prescience questions for all battles fought in a single combat round?...
Well, I guess I muddied the waters alittle with that short answer. My bad. Bidding happens like everything else sorta. And tere may be something lost in...
No, I don't think that is the case, I think in general, a karama only affects one player at a time. But, a karama played on the Atreides during the bidding to...
The following DuneBoardGame poll is now closed. Here are the final results: POLL QUESTION: When you play Dune, which of the following rules/expansions do you...
DuneBoardGame@yahoogr...
May 22, 2008 1:55 pm
1779
Enter your vote today! A new poll has been created for the DuneBoardGame group: Some controversy has arisen regarding the use of a Karama on the Atreides to...
DuneBoardGame@yahoogr...
May 22, 2008 1:59 pm
1780
I attempted to find Brad's clarifications, but couldn't find them. Can someone post a link to those helpful clarifications? I've also created a poll so...
Reading the rules, section XXV.4 says that a Karama prevents Atreides from looking at all the cards up for bid. This is an exception, usually karamas are "one...
... Thank David. It is indeed right there in the Q&A at the end of the rulebook. I think I'd bump that ability up maybe 3 spots in the rankings now....at...
Haven't actually played in years, but I would have to put your 5 as my 1. The K isn't just 2 more points in a battle. It's freedom from treachery. Can't...
Unless this is another situation where someone just doesn't feel like following the rules, there should be no controversy. In the original rulebook, Section...
It's coming up on a month with nothing new posted, so I thought that I'd throw something up here... I don't know how many of you hang out on Boardgame Geek,...
That's really pretty impressive work. I'm looking forward to seeing how it turns out. What are you going to do as far as the battle wheels are concerned? Are...
I'd like to replace all of the parts of the game, but I'm still working on the details. I'd like to do new battle wheels out of wood, but the obvious choice is...
One thing you could do for the cards, is to get plastic sleeves (that are commonly used in Collectable Card Games, then either use the same cards, or blow them...
I've used Blue Panther Inc to make custom wood tile cards for me before - they use laser cutting and they came out quite good. They also do Piecepacks :) ...
Hi, I am looking for a player for a 9-player dune game we are setting up. Deadlines end every 2 days but because of the high number of players, except during...
I'm a very experienced 6-player Dune player, but only face-to-face. I'll give it a try if you can't find anyone more suitable. I check e-mail every day...
I might be interested, though I've never played before, neither online nor face to face, so I'm a real beginner! I have read the rules several times, though. ...
Having problems with message search?
Fill out this form to ensure your group is one of the first to be migrated to the new message search system.
