the real problem is, that the recoil result gives an advantage some percent of the cases, so being of a class that you can calculate on that result to occur...
... commands when each command is broken, easy to keep track of, no distances to worry about, no playing the rules for affect like 6th ed. ... I concur it is...
... <snip> One certainly did it with Knights. Can you HONESTLY believe that HORSES would be in a condition to fight after being put into a merchant vessel?...
Hear hear. It will turn games into a contest to be the first to break an enemy command, as whoever does that first is almost guaranteed to win the game. Peter...
Barrett, Peter
Peter.Barrett@...
May 1, 2006 4:17 pm
33378
As a minimally experienced player (maybe 4 games under my belt) then interpenetration rules are as confusing as the baggage rules. It would be great if these...
In DBMMlist@yahoogroups.com, "Scott Nicholas" <nwa@...> wrote: "Ian Nicoll" daisho1965@... --- <snip> One certainly did it with Knights. Can you HONESTLY...
How long had the Samurai horses been in the boats before the landing? Similarly how long were the Norman horses at sea in the examples quoted and were they...
... from the old rules: Blades can be passed through by Auxilia or Bows except (X) if facing the same direction. from the new rules: Auxilia or Bows except (X)...
Hi gang, The rule also covers WW as rivers – so the impressed horses might be on boats for less than an hour? Who knows? Who cares? it is a useful game ...
... # Hello Jim, ok you asked for an example-here is one from 'Soldiers of the Faith' by Ronald C Finucane pp90-91 "The first attack on Constantinople in the...
... General ... My experience has been that a victorious command is frequently reduced to a host of fragmented elements who hare off in pursuit of the routing...
... serious ... break an ... win ... With the greatest of respect to you both, this is rubbish and not my experience. I have had many games where the side who...
... <Snip> ... <Snip> English ... AW - well done Norman. Another excellent wite up of an interesting test. On your Agincourt scenario I've been meaning to...
... description ... undertaking ... the horse ... method was ... horses. ... latter was ... Hi Scott, Firstly, it was Yoshitsune, not Yoshitsube. But we're not...
... What were the Greeks? Were they outnumbered? According to the rules, you could have ten times the number of seasoned veteran Bd(S) Romans on the beach and...
... <Snip> moot point, however, as we're talking about the advantage that ... AW - In your view of the relative benefits of the two have you considered...
... No, I didn't miss the point... perhaps YOU did. You continue to state that Bd can interpenetrate Ax and Bw, but they can't. Here's the rules again......
... <Snip> AW - I'm not sure, but I would have thought the Germans as Omaha would either have been in ambush, so unaffected, or not within 400p of the waters...
... Oh boy. I've considered this. It doesn't matter whether there is an increased risk, it doesn't matter if the risk is 99%... what matters is that the rules...
... It's got nothing to DO with how close you are to the waters edge. It isn't a 'flee' due to being too close to an outflank. The rule says: "Elements...
... shipping? ... shipping ... no such ... increased ... the ... AW - Obviously we come at this from different angles. To my mind the use of impressed...
... <Snip> ... for ... mounted ... rules, ... behind? ... AW - Quite so. However from my minimal knowledge of Agincourt, should the English army be 500 bows...
... because ... would ... the ... It ... rear ... <Snip> AW - Ah, another mistake by me. Still the germans at Omaha would not have had to make room as they...
Having problems with message search?
Fill out this form to ensure your group is one of the first to be migrated to the new message search system.
