Wanted to ressurect this thread as it was a good one full of tactical insight and ideas from many posters ;-) My question...rather than have Germany "hole up"...
... The question if not if Germany can take the Caucasus - Germany often has a mathematically favourable (i.e. ? 50% chance to capture) chance to do that - the...
<<<> FWIW, I agree that the attack W.Russia and attack Belorussia is a fine ... Interesting. Presumably you favor the triple opening? (Bel, Ukr, WRu - I'll...
I sorta lean towards the Ukraine/West Russia attack pattern now, and I stick an AA gun in Ukraine after it's taken with 2-3 tanks. Any fighters sent to retake...
Hi all. I am new to the group and have only played AA three times. All three times the Allies were unable to really touch Germany, even though KGF was the...
... In my experience, a fairly common plan is for the US to use a 3 by 3 transport system* along with a US controlled Norway and an IC for an additional 3...
I already see the Norway IC Strategy, too! Sometimes also played by the UK, although I think it's an error, better let the USA buy and manage that factory. UK...
Yo, This topic has seen a lot of action on this and other boards. The question is, what do you do with the Russians on their first turn? The answer has...
Very good argument for beeing aggressive! I quite always am in A&A and not always does it pay, but now I'm far more sure of my style! :) Now, we can have a...
Excellent commentary M-A-F ...I enjoy reading your well-thought out and clearly expressed strategy perspectives ! I'm curious though...you say you prefer K-G-F...
Good analysis, MAF. I too like playing an agressive Russia in a KGF game. But as Scipio mentioned, there are other options of aggression rather than the...
Good post, MAF. I think it would be worth listing your breakdown of how you divide your forces between the 3 territories. You have a couple of subtleties that...
I think that we already said something about Russia R1 for a KJF in some previous topics, try to check out or else start a new topic on this, it's a good...
Although I'm also not a great fan of the BELO attack if I already attack W.RUS and UKR, I can see what's the advantage of this move. That 3 German inf are the...
Excellent posts. Could you also post your buy and reasoning for it? There's 4 common R1 buys: 8 inf (all defensive) 4 inf, 3 art (helps set up Russian kill...
Good post. I think what's brilliant is the reasoning of the order of the battles and such. I would assume that your attacks are like this: 3 inf from Karelia +...
I would like to see the unit breakdown for each territory as well. Im finding it hard to get enough units into each zone to make it worth it. I guess Im just a...
Greetings all, first, I'm flattered by all the input, glad to see many of you are getting something out of the input. Let me try to answer as much as I have...
Ok, here's what I have to say: Based on your attacks, I believe it's about 55% overall to win all the fights. 72% in Belorussia (3 inf 1 arm vs 3 inf), 90% in...
Oh I made a mistake about the overall 55% calculation in my previous post. If you goal is to actually take those territories then perhaps the number is a bit...
I'd challenge that assessment and agree with the original poster who said it's "quite unlikely". I am surprised that you'd consider 10% failure rate NOT "quite...
You can challenge all you like about my opinion about what is quite unlikely and what is not, but can you challenge me on the math? Are your chances really...
By the way, your example is quite limited. I play a lot of A&A games, and 10% is a noticeable margin of error. It does not fall under "quite unlikely." If a...
oh I don't disagree with you on the 50 / 52 % aspect...and I don't doubt your math on the other areas either...I just meant that (in general) most people would...
To those who have Odds calculators handy...can you guys give me a quick assessment of my chances as Germany VS. London this upcoming round ? We are in...
The dice sim I use isn't fancy enough to factor in your first round bonus, but without it defenders win about 54% of the time while attackers win 44% of the...
RE: Sea Lion With your capabilities, it appears that you can not only hit UK decently 1 turn, but then follow up a second turn, probably with more than the...
Hi all - First time poster....been reading for a while. Love the analysis - thinking of making a tourney but hate to go all that way and get my a$$ kicked....
