I was only trying to demonstrate that if it was an innocent third party, you were magnanimous enough to let them have the last word Phil No. don't respond....
In recent weeks, I have supported suggestions that we address some persistent 'bad habits' in Armati play ... the corner hugging, the 'one flank' syndrome, the...
Some good points Phil. It seems to me that the issue of cavalry/ flank based victories is not that they are historically unsound, but that they happen too...
... wrong. ... Hellenistic ... (it ... quantity ... strangeness ... the ... to ... Ah, Whilst Pikes may not often be decisive in Hellenistic battles I do not...
I am more and more liking the two suggestions that: a) HC which move more that 12" gain a fatigue point (which can be rallied off in the usual manner); and: b)...
Oddly enough when A2 came out I played for a couple of months before I realised that exhausted HC still made HI fight with Flank factors if they contacted a...
Enter your vote today! A new poll has been created for the ARMATI group: Should HC/CATS/KNS that move 12" or more gain a fatigue point which can be rallied...
ARMATI@yahoogroups.com
Apr 1, 2007 8:02 pm
27225
Enter your vote today! A new poll has been created for the ARMATI group: Should Fatigued HC automatically break a unit with a successful flank attack? o Yes o...
... be fatigued. As for cavalry it means that they will be disadvantaged against LI and LHI even further because it will often mean arriving with one fatigue...
I wish I could explain all the nuances of ancient armies, Roy (:o)...) I think it _is clear that the depth of the phalanx is varied in order to avoid being...
In a message dated 4/1/2007 1:54:48 PM Pacific Daylight Time, elm.farm@... writes: This is unworkable catsand knights will move 11.99 inches and not...
In a message dated 4/1/2007 1:56:04 PM Pacific Daylight Time, elm.farm@... writes: Does this mean one fatigue? two fatigues or three? Before putting...
--Yes its a no and Stephen , even you can measure a bit further along the coloured stick than 11 inches but not quite to its end. That would nullify the point...
... As you said Phil, much agreement:-) The actions of the phalanx tactical iuse is that it does depend on what equipment and tactics the enemy are deploying....
It was a difficult argument to follow and had some good input. I did mail earlier with a further adjustment but this seems to have arrived just ahead of the...
I'm not too concerned about the speed of cavalry, I am concerned that if we start mucking about with cavalry speed (including fatigue for using cavalry's...
*Sigh* I try to slow exactly what you describe here and I get jumped on. I try to come at the matter from the other side by helping pat the prose together and...
I find it rather heartening that the biggest line so far is saying no change is needed at all to HC etc. Perhaps I have not been as isolated as some would have...
... As I've said, I don't have all the answers, Peter ... It may be you need to have Alexander present, be veteran*, win the initiative, and have something...
Just a small point. Cat & KN moving more than 12" should not only receive a fatigue point - their owner should be escorted to the door for blatant cheating! ...
Wow, you go away on holiday for a weekend and miss out on all this arguing... I must do it more often ;) Anyway, some comments on the various posts since...
A good point wittily put Steve. Armati has enough millimetre movement at the moment, working out whether a unit has moved its full move or not is going to be...
Having problems with message search?
Fill out this form to ensure your group is one of the first to be migrated to the new message search system.
